|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 6 | Page : 2693-2698
Assessment of fluoride levels during pregnancy and its association with early adverse pregnancy outcomes
Lajya Devi Goyal1, Dapinder Kaur Bakshi2, Jatinder Kaur Arora2, Ankita Manchanda3, Paramdeep Singh4
1 Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bathinda, Punjab, India
2 Division of Biotechnology, Punjab State Council for Science and Technology, Chandigarh, Punjab, India
3 Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Guru Gobind Singh Medical College and Hospital, Baba Farid University of Health Sciences, Faridkot, Punjab, India
4 Department of Radiology, Guru Gobind Singh Medical College and Hospital, Baba Farid University of Health Sciences, Faridkot, Punjab, India
|Date of Submission||05-Feb-2020|
|Date of Decision||13-Mar-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||13-Apr-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||30-Jun-2020|
Dr. Paramdeep Singh
Department of Radiology, Guru Gobind Singh (GGS) Medical College and Hospital, Baba Farid University of Health Sciences, Faridkot, Punjab
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background and Aim: There is sparse data available on human subjects regarding the affect of excessive fluoride exposures on pregnancy. The aim of this study was to examine the association between elevated urinary fluoride levels during early pregnancy and maternal anemia and adverse fetal outcome. Patients and Methods: We enrolled 600 pregnant patients with gestational age less than 20 weeks and with a high urinary fluoride levels(>1 mg/L).We also documented the fluoride levels in the tap water and ground water samples collected from the areas where these women resided during pregnancy. These patients were also evaluated for hemoglobin levels and detailed fetal examination by ultrasound. Data was assessed by SSPS version 16.0 software and P < 0.05 was considered to be significant. Results: Urinary fluoride averaged 2.65 mg/L and ranged from 1.0 to 4.3 mg/L while all the water samples revealed fluoride levels greater than WHO prescribed the limit of 1.5 mg/L. A total of 402 patients (67%) were found to be anemic with hemoglobin levels ranging from 6.2 to 11.9 g/dl (9.28 ± 1.29). Eighty one patients (13.5%) had adverse fetal outcomes that comprised abortions, congenital abnormalities, and intrauterine deaths (IUDs). There was a negative correlation between urinary fluoride and hemoglobin levels (P = 0.031, r= -0.59) and females with elevated urinary fluoride levels were found to have a strong association with the pregnancy complications, i.e., anemia, miscarriage, abortion, and still birth (χ2 = 9.23, P < 0.05). Conclusions: Excess fluoride exposures can have deleterious effects on the expecting mother and fetus and is associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes.
Keywords: Complications, fetus, fluoride, fluorosis, pregnancy
|How to cite this article:|
Goyal LD, Bakshi DK, Arora JK, Manchanda A, Singh P. Assessment of fluoride levels during pregnancy and its association with early adverse pregnancy outcomes. J Family Med Prim Care 2020;9:2693-8
|How to cite this URL:|
Goyal LD, Bakshi DK, Arora JK, Manchanda A, Singh P. Assessment of fluoride levels during pregnancy and its association with early adverse pregnancy outcomes. J Family Med Prim Care [serial online] 2020 [cited 2020 Sep 19];9:2693-8. Available from: http://www.jfmpc.com/text.asp?2020/9/6/2693/287848
| Introduction|| |
Fluoride is one of the vital elements affecting human health as its deficiency leads to faulty enamel formation and the excess causes dental, skeletal, and extra skeletal fluorosis. Therefore, it is important to keep the fluoride ingestion at an optimum level. Fluorosis is one of the important public health issues in many parts of the developing world. In India many areas are fluoride endemic and around 25 million people are currently affected by fluorosis. Like many other countries, India is also located in the topographical fluoride belt where owing to high fluoride amount in rocks or soil, the leakage of fluoride happens, causing surplus fluoride level in groundwater.,, Drinking water is usually the chief source of fluoride.
In many developing countries fluoride quantity in drinking water is much more than the safe prescribed limits. The maximum appropriate limit for fluoride levels in drinking water has been fixed as 1.0 mg/L by the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), and allowable limit in the lack of another source has been set as 1.5 mg/L. Too much fluoride in drinking water causes fluorosis that is seen in endemic proportions in many parts of the world. Nearly 20 states of India have been recognized as endemic for fluorosis and around 66 million people living in these areas are at the danger of fluoride contamination. Fluoride intake through groundwater is the major cause of fluorosis and has become one of the most critical issues affecting human health.,,
Reports on trans placental fluoride passage suggest that fluoride is transmitted through placenta to the fetus while the benefit of fluoride intake during human pregnancy is still debatable. Not much is known about excess fluoride exposure during pregnancy and its affect on pregnancy outcome. The state of Punjab is one of the fluorosis endemic zones in India. Faridkot, with its semi-arid weather and dependence on ground water for drinking, makes it vulnerable to be one of the fluorosis endemic districts of Punjab. The present study was conducted among pregnant women from lower socioeconomic strata from Faridkot district of the state of Punjab (India) in order to know the urinary fluoride levels and its association with hemoglobin levels and adverse fetal outcomes during early periods of gestation. This study further aims to improve our knowledge regarding excess fluoride exposure during pregnancy.
| Patients and Methods|| |
In the period of years 2015 to 2017, we recruited 600 women from prenatal clinics of our tertiary care teaching hospital with the following inclusion criteria: Ability to communicate in the local language, above 18 years of age, gestational age less than 20 weeks, and those who provided written informed consent. Following were the exclusion criteria: Mental illnesses, addiction to alcohol or illegal drugs, high-risk pregnancies, Pre-eclampsia, renal disease, hypertension, gestational diabetes, abnormal biochemical indicators, and those who were more than 20 weeks pregnant or there was a known fetal abnormality in the previous off springs. The sample size was calculated as 396 based on the prevalence of fluorosis (4.1%) as per study done by Plaka K, et al. at 95% confidence interval and precision (d) as the half of prevalence and assuming 10% attrition. This study was approved by the Institutional Ethical Committee vide letter no. BFUHS/IEC/15/170 dated 17th October 2015. The information regarding socio-economic profile and source of water for intake, cooking, and other day-to-day purposes, type of foodstuffs eaten and the usage of fluoride-containing commodities were documented. Following parameters were estimated and documented in the patients: Gestational age, hemoglobin levels, and fluoride amount in urine.
Estimation of fluoride and hemoglobin levels
The free ionic form of fluoride was calculated in urine samples by employing an ion-selective electrode-based assay (Thermo-Scientific Orion 4 star) and those patients with level above 1.0 mg/l were included in the study. These patients were divided into three groups based on the urinary fluoride levels ranging between: 1–1.9, 2–2.9, and ≥ 3 mg/L. Hemoglobin assessment was done by cyanomethemoglobin method. Based on the hemoglobin levels, patients were divided into 4 groups as per the Indian Council of Medical Research categories of anemia in pregnancy  i.e. mild (10–10.9), moderate (7.0–10.0), severe (<7), very severe (<4).
These patients were further evaluated for the following factors: Diet survey for assessment of the source of fluoride in food consumed as well as use of fluoridated toothpaste, mouth rinses, cosmetics etc., Water samples used by these patients for cooking and drinking purpose were collected and the fluoride levels were assessed using fluoride ion specific electrode. The data of fluoride, hemoglobin levels, and ultrasound findings were documented. Patients with high fluoride level - >1 mg/l) were recommended nutritional intervention and were counseled to use alternate safe water source with low fluoride level. Further, evidence-based material such as posters/banners/brochures portraying the reasons and prevention of fluorosis were printed in the local language. Awareness workshops for the information of pregnant and other patients on fluorosis and its prevention were organized in the affected villages.
Assessment of fetal parameters and pregnancy complications by ultrasound
Gestational age was assessed by fetal biometry on an ultrasound scan using a Philips Affinity 70 machine (PhilipsHealthcare, Best, The Netherlands). Crown-rump length (CRL) was used to assess the gestational age before 14 weeks and after 14 weeks, the measurements comprised biparietal diameter (BPD), head circumference (HC), abdominal circumference (AC) and femur length (FL). HC and AC were obtained using the ellipse measurement instrument, by positioning the calipers on the outer edges of the circumference. Fetal heart rate was calculated by M-mode ultrasound and was documented. Any congenital abnormality and the status of placenta and amniotic fluid was also documented. Ultrasound examination was done during 1st trimester of pregnancy and was repeated in 2nd trimester of pregnancy at around 18 weeks of pregnancy to look for any congenital abnormalities.
The data was sorted out in Microsoft Excel and the results were statistically evaluated by the Student's t-test, Pearson's correlation coefficient, and chi square test whereever indicated. Results were assessed by SSPS version 16.0 for windows (SSPS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). A probability value (P value) of < 0.05 was considered as significant.
| Results|| |
Sociodemographic profile of patients
All the patients (n = 600) in the present study were the residents of Faridkot district of Punjab, India out of which 420 patients (70%) belonged to rural areas [Table 1]. These patients used tap water or ground water for drinking and house hold purposes. Most of the patients were either illiterate (21%) or had schooling till primary level (45%) and belonged to lower or upper lower socio-economic class as per socio-economic status scale.
|Table 1: Showing socio-demographic profiles, urinary fluoride concentrations and hemoglobin levels of pregnant patients|
Click here to view
Ground and tap water samples were collected and the fluoride levels in the water samples were 2.35 ± 0.39mg/l (range 2.1–3.3 mg/l) and 2.4 ± 0.25 mg/l (range 1.9–2.8 mg/l), respectively. All (100%) the ground water and tap samples showed fluoride concentration more than the WHO prescribed limit of 1.5 mg/L. No significant difference in fluoride levels was seen in water and urinary samples collected from rural or urban areas and from tap or ground water (P > 0.05). Urinary Fluoride levels averaged 2.65 mg/L and ranged from 1.0 to 4.3 mg/L. Based on the urinary fluoride levels, these patients were divided into three groups Group 1 (1–1.9 mg/l; n = 155), Group 2 (2–2.9 mg/l; n = 199) and Group 3 (≥3 mg/l; n = 246)[Table 1].
Hemoglobin (Hb) levels
Overall hemoglobin levels in the patients ranged from 6.2–11.9 g/dl (mean; SD 9.28 ± 1.29). A total of 402 patients (67%) were anemic based on the ICMR criteria of anemia during pregnancy. Based on the hemoglobin (Hb) levels, the patients were divided into four groups as per above criteria [Table 1]. Majority of the anemic patients (70.8%) had moderately low Hb levels and hence belonged to 2nd group.
Elevated urinary fluoride levels, maternal anemia, and adverse fetal outcomes
Nearly 80% of the patients in group 3 of the urinary fluoride concentration were anemic, while 63% and 36% were anemic in group 2 and group 1, respectively and this difference between the groups was statistically significant (P < 0.05). There was a negative correlation between urinary fluoride and hemoglobin levels and this inverse relation was statistically significant (P = 0.031, r= -0.59).
A total of 81 patients (13.5%) had adverse fetal outcomes that included abortions, congenital abnormalities, and intrauterine deaths (IUD). Out of these 81 patients, 34 (42%) had obvious congenital abnormalities that were detected on ultrasound done at the 18 weeks of gestation. Of these 34 patients, ultrasound detected 30 patients with neural tube defects and 4 patients with cardiac abnormalities. Rest of the 47 patients (58%) had either abortions (n = 35; 74%) or IUD's (n = 12; 26%) that were confirmed on ultrasound examination [Figure 1]. Nearly 16% of the patients in group 3 of the urinary fluoride concentration, 13% patients of group 2, and 10% of group 3 had adverse fetal outcomes, though this difference between groups was not statistically significant (P > 0.05)[Table 2]; [Figure 2]. Females with elevated urinary fluoride levels were found to have a strong association with the pregnancy complications i.e. anemia, miscarriage, abortion, still birth, and congenital anomalies (χ2 = 9.23, P < 0.05).
|Figure 1: Ultrasound image from a patient with neural tube defect showing gross hydrocephalous with thinning of the parenchyma|
Click here to view
|Table 2: Showing data of different fluoride concentration groups and adverse pregnancy outcomes|
Click here to view
|Figure 2: Bar diagram showing different fluoride levels groups and the pregnancy complications|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Fluoride in drinking water is accepted for both useful and harmful effects on health. Fluorosis is prevalent in many developing Asian and African countries in the form of “linked disorders” as fluoride being a reactive ion and an oxidizing agent acts as an enzyme inhibitor, hormone disruptor, and neurotoxin.,,,, Because of more than 90% bioavailability, the consumption of excess of fluoride through drinking water is one of the main causes of fluorosis., We examined a group of 600 pregnant women of reproductive age group from lower socioeconomic strata who were regularly exposed to fluoride by means of drinking water with the aim of detecting the early adverse pregnancy outcomes comprising abortions, IUDs, and congenital abnormalities. This study was done in Faridkot district of Punjab, India and on the examination of groundwater and tap water, it was detected that the mean value of the water fluoride content was 2.4 mg/L that is more than the permissible limits. As per the WHO guidelines the maximum allowable limit of fluoride in drinking water is 1.5 mg/L, whereas according to the BIS the safer limit is around 1 mg/L. Hence, it may be concluded that the exposure to fluoride from drinking water is of considerable concern in this region.
Other factors such as diet, excessive tea consumption, other concomitant nutritional deficiencies, and, the usage of fluoridated tooth paste have also an effect on the occurrence and severity of fluorosis. The patients enrolled in our study mainly dependeded on locally grown vegetarian food for their day-to-day supplies and had a history of regular intake of tea and usage of Fluoridated toothpastes. In the present study, 402 patients (67%) were anemic based on the ICMR criteria of anemia during pregnancy. Further, there was a negative correlation between urinary fluoride and hemoglobin levels. Vitamin B12 is one of the important elements of hemoglobin and is manufactured by probiotic bacteria in the gut that are diminished by excessive fluoride leading to anemia. The excess consumption of fluoride also leads to non absorption of nutrients due to the damage of intestinal microvilli. Hillman et al. documented that levels of serum folic acid and vitamin B12 in body were reduced by fluoride overdose leading to anemia in cattle. Another study from India documented that anemia in school children was owing to consuming drinking water with high fluoride level and there was a inverse relationship between urinary fluoride and hemoglobin levels.
Although plasma fluoride level is a contemporary biomarker for intake of fluoride, still urine has been counted as the very valuable biomarker for fluoride intake since it is commonly used, comparatively simple to collect, and non invasive., Possible harm to the developing embryo and fetus in the backdrop of high maternal intake of fluoride has been a source of concern, with only very few studies evaluating this risk in humans. In the present study we found that females with elevated urinary fluoride levels have more chances of pregnancy complications such as anemia and adverse fetal outcomes. Fluoride crosses the placenta and it has been documented that the mean umbilical cord blood levels of fluoride are around 60% of maternal serum levels. Unfavorable perinatal outcomes such as pre term and small-for-gestational-age infants and the increased incidence of perinatal mortality have been found in the offspring of the anemic mothers. Evidence from some of the human studies suggests that excessive fluoride influences neural development in utero and can lead to neurological malformations.,,,,,, In a paper published by AK Susheela et al. it was found that the intake of fluoride free water and food decreased the incidence of preterm deliveries by 4 times and low birth weight babies by 2 times. This paper also documented that iron and folate supplementations to the pregnant women decreased the possibility of low birth weight only if these supplements are accompanied by nutritional food and less fluoride intake.
Family physicians are the essential contributors of care for females of the reproductive-age group that incorporates healthcare before, during, and after pregnancy. Primary care physicians are uniquely poised to guide patients regarding excessive fluoride exposures during pregnancy; by designing and conducting awareness programmes, by discussing harmful effects of fluorosis including adverse pregnancy outcomes and by contributing towards its management by focusing on timely treatment, healthy diets, and safe drinking water. Further, family physicians can synchronize the healthcare of such pregnant patients among different specialties, which can ultimately lead to better health outcomes.
The drawback of this study was that mainly drinking water was examined for fluoride content and patients were followed only till 20 weeks of gestation. The amount of fluoride intake due to food and drinks such as tea was not determined. We feel that further studies are needed in order to recognize more factors related with adverse pregnancy outcomes due to water contaminants and the findings of the present study ought to be corroborated in other study populations. Hence, multicentric studies with a larger sample size and with a regular monitoring of 24-hour urine samples along with plasma samples may lead to the better understanding of the deleterious effects of excessive fluoride exposures during pregnancy. Nevertheless, our study has highlighted this important public health issue and is likely to set a benchmark for other studies on this subject so that this issue can be explored in depth. Based on the findings of this research the authors would like to make following recommendations:
- All the pregnant patients residing in fluoride endemic areas should be screened for anemia and high urinary fluoride levels, as the later test is simple, non invasive and inexpensive.
- Ultrasound examination is recommended at prescribed intervals for patients with high urinary fluoride levels to look for any congenital anomalies and other adverse fetal outcomes. Therefore, family physicians have an important role to play in minimizing the complications by conducting an early screening of this disease and hence ensuring timely treatment.
- Further, efforts must be made to address the low level of health literacy about fluorosis as well as the prevalent dietary habits and behaviors that lead to excessive fluoride exposures.
| Conclusions|| |
The study confirms the presence of excess fluoride levels in the underground and tap water of Faridkot district of north India. Excess fluoride intake during early pregnancy may lead to increased prevalence and severity of maternal anemia as well as adverse fetal outcomes in the form of miscarriages, abortions, intra-uterine deaths, and congenital malformations. Further, multicentric studies with large study populations are required in order to better establish the relationship of the excess fluoride exposures with adverse pregnancy outcomes.
Declaration of patient consent
The authors certify that they have obtained all appropriate patient consent forms. In the form the patients have given consent for their images and other clinical information to be reported in the journal. The patients understand that their names and initials will not be published and due efforts will be made to conceal their identity.
The authors would like to thank Dr. Amarpreet Kaur, MD, Associate Professor, Department of Pediatrics, Guru Gobind Singh (GGS) Medical College and Hospital, Faridkot (Punjab) for help in statistical analysis of this study.
Financial support and sponsorship
This study was done with the help of a research grant from Punjab State Council for Science and Technology, Chandigarh, India.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Fluorosis: An easily preventable disease through practice of interventions. In: Susheela AK, editor. Doctor's Handbook. 1st
ed. New Delhi: Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (GOI) and WHO India Country Office; 2005. p. 1-21.
Rocha-Amador D, Navarro ME, Carrizales L, Morales R, Calderon J. Decreased intelligence in children and exposure to fluoride and arsenic in drinking water. Cad Saude Publica 2007;23(Suppl 4):S579-87.
Reddy DR. Neurology of endemic skeletal fluorosis. Neurol India 2009;57:7-12.
] [Full text]
Indermitte E, Saava A, Karro E. Exposure to high fluoride drinking water and risk of dental fluorosis in Estonia. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2009;6:710-21.
Shruthi MN, Anil NS. A comparative study of dental fluorosis and non-skeletal manifestations of fluorosis in areas with different water fluoride concentrations in rural Kolar. J Family Med Prim Care 2018;7:1222-8.
] [Full text]
Gedalia I, Brzezinski A, Bercovici B, Lazarov E. Placental transfer of fluoride in the human fetus. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 1961;106:147-9.
Jolly SS, Singh BM, Mathur OC, Malhotra KC. Epidemiological, clinical and biochemical study of endemic dental and skeletal fluorosis in Punjab. Brit Med J 1968;4:427-9.
Plaka K, Ravindra K, Mor S, Gauba K. Risk factors and prevalence of dental fluorosis and dental caries in school children of North India. Environ Monit Assess 2017;189:40.
Sharma JB, Shankar M. Anaemia in pregnancy. J Int Med Sci Acad 2010;23:253-60.
Sharma R. Revised Kuppuswamy's socioeconomic status scale: Explained and updated. Indian Pediatr 2017; 54:867-70.
Johnston NR, Strobel SA. Principles of fluoride toxicity and the cellular response: A review. Arch ToxicolArch Toxicol 2020. doi: 10.1007/s00204-020-02687-5. [Epub ahead of print]
Jiang N, Guo F, Xu W, Zhang Z, Jin H, Shi L, et al
. Effect offluoride on osteocyte-driven osteoclastic differentiation. Toxicology 2020:152429. doi: 10.1016/j.tox. 2020.152429. [Epub ahead of print]
Qing-Feng S, Ying-Peng X, Tian-Tong X. Matrix metalloproteinase-9 and p53 involved in chronic fluorosis induced blood-brain barrier damage and neurocyte changes. Arch Med Sci 2019;15:457-66.
Chaitanya NCSK, Karunakar P, Allam NSJ, Priya MH, Alekhya B, Nauseen S. A systematic analysis on possibility of water fluoridation causing hypothyroidism. Indian J Dent Res 2018;29:358-63.
] [Full text]
Demelash H, Beyene A, Abebe Z, Melese A. Fluoride concentration in ground water and prevalence of dental fluorosis in Ethiopian Rift Valley: Systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Public Health 2019;19:1298.
Susheela AK, Toteja GS. Prevention and control of fluorosis and linked disorders: Developments in the 21st
Century-Reaching out to patients in the community and hospital settings for recovery. Indian J Med Res 2018;148:539-47.
] [Full text]
Akuno MH, Nocella G, Milia EP, Gutierrez L. Factors influencing the relationship between fluoride in drinking water and dental fluorosis: A ten-yearsystematic review and meta-analysis. J Water Health. 2019;17:845-62.
Mahantesha T, Dixit UB, Nayakar RP, Ashwin D, Ramagoni NK, Kamavaram Ellore VP. Prevalence of dental fluorosis and associated risk factors in Bagalkot District, Karnataka, India. Int J Clin Pediatr Dent 2016;9:256-63.
Susheela AK, Mondal NK, Rashmi G, Sethi M, Pandey RM. Fluorosis is linked to anaemia. Curr Sci 2018;115:692-700.
Hillman D, Bolenbaugh DL, Convey EM. Hypothyroidism and anemia related to fluoride in dairy cattle. J Dairy Sci 1979;62:416-23.
Susheela AK, Gupta R, Mondal NK. Anaemia in adolescent girls: An intervention of diet editing and counselling. Natl Med J India 2016;29:200-4.
] [Full text]
Kumar S, Lata S, Yadav JP, Yadav JP. Relationship between water, urine and serum fluoride and fluorosis in school children of Jhajjar District, Haryana, India. Appl Water Sci 2016;7:3377-84.
Idowu OS, Azevedo LB, Valentine RA, Swan J, Vasantavada PV, Maguire A, et al
. The use of urinary fluoride excretion to facilitate monitoring fluoride intake: A systematic scoping review. PLoS One 2019;14:e0222260.
Gupta S, Seth AK, Gupta A, Gavane AG. Transplacental passage of fluorides. J Pediatr 1993;123:139-41.
Gurumurthy Sastry M, Mohanty S, Bhongir AV, Mishra AK, Rao P. Association of higher maternal serum fluoride with adverse fetal outcomes. Int J Med Public Health 2011;1:13-7.
Washino N, Saijo Y, Sasaki S, Kato S, Ban S, Konishi K, et al
. Correlations between prenatal exposure to perfluorinated chemicals and reduced fetal growth. Environ Health Perspect 2009;117:660-7.
Apelberg BJ, Witter FR, Herbstman JB, Calafat AM, Halden RU, Needham LL, et al
. Cord serum concentrations of perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS) and perfluorooctanoate (PFOA) in relation to weight and size at birth. Environ Health Perspect 2007;115:1670-6.
Green R, Lanphear B, Hornung R, Flora D, Martinez-Mier EA, Neufeld R, et al
. Association between maternal fluoride exposure during pregnancy and IQ scores in Offspring in Canada. JAMA Pediatr2019. doi: 10.1001/jamapediatrics. 2019.1729. [Epub ahead of print]
Du L. The effect of fluorine on the developing human brain. Zhonghua Bing Li Xue Za Zhi 1992;21:218-20.
Susheela AK, Mondal NK, Gupta R, Ganesh K, Brahmankar S, Bhasin S, et al
. Effective interventional approach to control anaemia in pregnant women. Curr Sci 2010;98:1320-30.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2]
[Table 1], [Table 2]