|Year : 2020 | Volume
| Issue : 7 | Page : 3657-3662
Maternal health-related barriers and the potentials of mobile health technologies: Qualitative findings from a pilot randomized controlled trial in rural Southwestern Uganda
Wilson Tumuhimbise1, Esther C Atukunda1, Sandrah Ayebaza1, Jane Katusiime1, Godfrey Mugyenyi1, Niels Pinkwart2, Angella Musiimenta3
1 Mbarara University of Science and Technology, Mbarara, Uganda
2 Humbold t-Universitat zu Berlin, Berlin, Germany
3 Mbarara University of Science and Technology; Angels Compassion Research and Innovations Centre, Mbarara, Uganda
|Date of Submission||18-Feb-2020|
|Date of Decision||14-Mar-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||19-May-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||30-Jul-2020|
Mr. Wilson Tumuhimbise
P.O. Box 1410, Mbarara
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: Maternal mortality rate remains unacceptably high in Uganda. In-depth evidence about the barriers to access and utilization of maternal health services specifically among the rural illiterate pregnant women remains lacking. The potentials of mobile health technologies in addressing the maternal health challenges remain unclear. Aim: To explore the maternal health-related barriers among illiterate pregnant women in rural Southwestern Uganda and highlight the potentials of mobile health technologies. Material and Methods: This is a midline qualitative study conducted with the participants of a pilot randomized controlled trial. Between October 2019 and December 2019, we carried out semi-structured interviews with 30 illiterate pregnant mothers. Interviews elicited information on the barriers to access and utilization of maternal health services. An inductive, content analytic approach was used to analyze qualitative data. Quantitative sociodemographic and socioeconomic data were summarized descriptively. Results: Participants reported that lack of money (for transport and medical costs), unfriendly maternal health services, and delays at the maternal health clinic constrain access and utilization of maternal health services. Given their widespread adoption, mobile technologies can potentially address some of these barriers e.g., money for transport or microenterprise start-up can be sent to women through their mobile phones or maternal health-related services (such as health education and consultation) can be provided electronically. Conclusion: Future efforts should focus on utilizing mobile health technologies to not only enable women overcome the critical financial challenges but also facilitate remote access and utilization of maternal health services.
Keywords: Barriers, illiterate pregnant women, maternal health access, mobile health technologies, service utilization
|How to cite this article:|
Tumuhimbise W, Atukunda EC, Ayebaza S, Katusiime J, Mugyenyi G, Pinkwart N, Musiimenta A. Maternal health-related barriers and the potentials of mobile health technologies: Qualitative findings from a pilot randomized controlled trial in rural Southwestern Uganda. J Family Med Prim Care 2020;9:3657-62
|How to cite this URL:|
Tumuhimbise W, Atukunda EC, Ayebaza S, Katusiime J, Mugyenyi G, Pinkwart N, Musiimenta A. Maternal health-related barriers and the potentials of mobile health technologies: Qualitative findings from a pilot randomized controlled trial in rural Southwestern Uganda. J Family Med Prim Care [serial online] 2020 [cited 2020 Sep 20];9:3657-62. Available from: http://www.jfmpc.com/text.asp?2020/9/7/3657/290782
| Introduction|| |
Maternal and child mortality rate still remain alarmingly high in low resource settings especially in sub-Saharan Africa. In 2017, of the 295,000 maternal deaths that occurred globally, 254,000 occurred in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asian countries alone, with sub-Saharan Africa alone accounting for an estimate of 66% and Southern Asia 20%. This report indicates that the rate of maternal mortality in Uganda currently stands at 375 per 100,000 live births-”which makes the country among the world's high maternal mortality rate countries. Majority of these deaths occur among the illiterate and poor women due to the lack of access to reliable information and quality maternal health services.
Ensuring the health and wellbeing of the pregnant mothers and their unborn babies is a global priority and a key component for the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) number 3-” “Ensure healthy lives and promote wellbeing at all ages”. Taking good care of pregnant women not only increases their survival rates but also results into giving birth to healthy babies, thus ensuring the health of families and communities. The SDGs advocate for reducing the global maternal mortality rates to less than 70 per 100,000 live births by 2030. However, the achievement of this target seems impossible in Uganda mainly due to predominantly lack of access to maternal health services especially among the illiterate pregnant women from rural poor communities.
The benefits of attending antenatal care include improved health of the mother and child, planned birth and emergence preparedness, as well as identification and management of obstetric complications and infections. Facility-based delivery results in timely management of maternal complications, and enables preventing mothers and new-borns from infections. The proportion of pregnant women attending antenatal care and delivering from healthcare facilities with support from skilled personnel in Uganda is still low. Only 58% of the pregnant mothers attend at least four recommended visits, and 57% women deliver from healthcare facilities in Uganda. Women from rural communities are twice less likely to attend antenatal care compared to their counterparts in urban settings. Attending antenatal care services is more pronounced among the literates compared to the illiterates in Uganda. Women with no education are 2.7 times at a risk of maternal mortality compared to their counterparts who were educated. Previous studies have documented some barriers to the utilization of maternal health services such as long distances to the health facilities and lack of supplies and drugs., These studies generally focused on pregnant women irrespective of their level of education. The barriers to access and utilization of maternal health services specifically among rural illiterate pregnant women remain unclear. In addition, the potentials of mobile phone-based interventions in addressing maternal health-related barriers particularly among illiterate women remain unknown. In this study, we explored the barriers that constrain the access and utilization of maternal healthcare among the illiterate pregnant women in rural Southwestern Uganda. We also discuss the potentials of using mobile technologies to address the maternal health-related challenges.
| Material And Methods|| |
Study design and setting
The study utilizes semi-structured interviews in a qualitative method study design. Participants (pregnant mothers) were recruited from the department of obstetrics and gynaecology, Mbarara Regional Referral Hospital (MRRH), which is the largest hospital in rural Southwestern Uganda. The MRRH employs 11 obstetricians and 22 midwives and performs over 10,000 deliveries annually with a maternal mortality rate of 270/100,000 live birth and cesarean section rate of 30% and a perinatal mortality rate of 56/1000. Sociodemographic and basic health data are captured from pregnant women during their first visit and stored in paper-based antenatal registers. Each woman is given an antenatal card that contains her biodata as well as the date of the next appointment. Women are expected to attend at least four antenatal appointments and they are supposed to bring their antenatal cards on every visit. The clinic verbally provides group-based health talks to women. The talks are scheduled according the trimesters-” first trimester talks are offered on Tuesdays, second trimester talks on Wednesdays, and third trimester health talks on Thursdays. The topics covered in these talks include nutrition and birth preparedness. There are currently no follow-up mechanisms for pregnant women who miss attending their antenatal appointments.
Selection of study participants
Between Jan 2019 and Dec 2019, we purposively selected 80 pregnant women receiving antenatal care from the department of obstetrics and gynaecology, Mbarara Regional Referral Hospital. Inclusion criteria were as follows: a) initiating antenatal care at MRRH at the earliest presentation in the first and second trimester, b) being illiterate (not having studied beyond primary seven or elementary education), c) 18 years and above, d) residents of Mbarara (within 20 km of MRRH), e) ability to use mobile phones, and f) willing and able to give informed consent.
These were women who were part of the study that was using a mobile phone-based multimedia application to support maternal health. The application was developed using Java programming language, while the database that hosts multimedia messages was developed using SQLite. It is an offline (stand-alone) application which does not run on the internet. It was developed following user-centred design approaches that involved incorporating input from pregnant women as prospective users. The application was installed on affordable smartphones provided by the study. Pregnant women were provided with solar chargers to supplement electricity charging. The application has three major functionalities;
- The video/audio function; which provides locally customized videos and audios that provide personalized maternal health information to pregnant women based on their pregnancy stages. Contents of the videos/audio messages include nutrition, breast feeding, HIV testing, spouse involvement, family planning, danger signs, preparing for child birth, care during pregnancy, care during delivery and postnatal care.
- The appointment reminder function allows the users to set the dates and reminders for their next antenatal care appointment.
- The calling function through which the pregnant women can communicate with health workers and ask pregnancy-related queries or application related issues.
It also has login module which uses pictorial password to allow access to the application.
From private space at a research office near the MRRH, WT and JK carried out semi-structured interviews with illiterate pregnant mothers between August 2019 to October 2019. Interviews were carried out until thematic saturation was achieved (i.e., until no new data was obtained) -” which occurred after the 30th participant. Each interview lasted between 40 and 50 minutes. All questions in the interview guide for women were translated into the local language (Runyankole) and back-translated to English by a different translator, after which the two versions were compared for accuracy. The interviews with pregnant women were carried out in Runyankole (local language), digitally recorded, transcribed, and translated to English. Interviews mainly elicited information about participants' understanding of the barriers that constrain them from accessing maternal health services. Following each interview, WT, AM, GM, and ECA reviewed the transcripts for quality, clarity, and detail. WT also administered surveys to pregnant women to collect information of their sociodemographic and socioeconomic status.
Inductive content analysis was used to derive categories describing and summarizing the participant's barriers to accessing maternal health services. Initially, AM and WT reviewed and discussed 20% of transcripts for content relevant to participants' barriers constraining the participant's access to maternal health services. Then the c odebook was assembled by AM and WT from the identified concepts, using an iterative process, which included developing codes to represent content, writing operational definitions, and selecting illustrative quotes. NP and ECA also reviewed and discussed the codebook. Following the completion of the codebook, AM and WT applied codes using NVIVO 11. Differences in coding were harmonized through discussion. TW and AM used STATA 13 to describe study participants' characteristics as indicated in [Table 1] and social economic status in [Table 2].
|Table 1: Socio-demographic and basic health status characteristics of study participants|
Click here to view
Human subjects and ethics approval
This study was approved by the Institutional Review Committee of Mbarara University of Science and Technology (No: 30/04-18), and the Uganda National Council for Science and Technology (no: SS 4661). All participants provided signed informed consent before study participation.
| Results|| |
As indicated in [Table 2] above, 31 (86.1%) had running water at home, while 33 (91.7%) had no regular income.
The following section documents barriers reported by pregnant women in relation to accessing and utilization of maternal health care in rural south western Uganda. The identified barriers were grouped into three themes: 1) lack of money for transport, and medical costs, 2) unfriendly maternal health services, and 3) delays at maternal health clinics.
Lack of money for transport and medical costs
The participants reported difficulties in the clinic due to lack of money for transport. Consequently, some participants borrowed money for transport from friends and relatives. Others ended up missing appointments and others did exhausting manual labour to raise the money. While others resorted to walking long distances, which resulted in reaching the clinics late.
R: I looked for transport to bring me today and I couldn't get it. I found myself in regrets of why I got this pregnancy. I decided to walk up to here, but it was a long distance, so I reached late, and they refused to attend to me. (Pregnant woman, 33 Years).
R. I had no money to come to the clinic, so, I borrowed from a friend. (Pregnant woman, 28 years).
Participants reported lack of money to meet medical costs such as ultrasound scans, as well as items required for delivery.
R: I went to the hospital and they required me to do a scan which I couldn't do then because I had no money. I had to go back and first look for money...I also did not manageto buy mama kit because I did not have money. (Pregnant woman, 24 Years).
In order to raise money to meet these necessities, some participants reported spending long hours of work to meet the costs and this has resulted into negative health issues.
R: I have to spend long hours working in people's gardens to get money to go to the hospital for antenatal visits and at some point I developed pain in my body because of working a lot. (Pregnant woman, 21 years).
Lack of friendly maternal health services
Participants reported lack of friendly maternal health services at antenatal clinics. This was manifested in the form of rude communication from healthcare workers or denial of services in case of coming late to the clinic. Consequently, some women missed antenatal care appointments or/and transferred to another clinic.
R. One day I walked and reached the hospital late, nurses refused to attend to me. I tried explaining to them, but they abused me sometimes. Now days when I see that I will be late, I don't bother coming, because I know I will be chased (Pregnant woman, 31 Years).
Delays at the clinic
Some participants highlighted long hours of waiting at the health facility moreover on empty stomachs. This sometimes results in not being attended to especially in instances when the staff on duty are few.
R: I come for antenatal check-up but they delay to work on us. We wait all day on empty stomachs-”they normally work on us in the evening mostly by 6:00pm. One time, I came to the hospital for antenatal check-up but there was only one nurse on duty. She collected our medical forms and got tired before she could work on all of us. So she told us to go back and come on a different day. (Pregnant woman, 25 years).
| Discussion|| |
Pregnant women reported lacking money to meet the cost of transport to the clinic and to pay medical costs such as ultrasound scans, as well as buying requirements necessary for delivery. Consequently, some women resorted to borrowing money for transport, others walked for long distances and ended up delaying to reach the clinic, while others ended up missing the scheduled appointments. Participants reported unfriendly maternal health services in the form of unkind words from healthcare providers or failing to be attended to when they reach late for their appointments or when they fail coming with particular requirements. This resulted into missing antenatal care (ANC) appointments or/and transferring to another clinic in search for friendly services. Being harsh to illiterate women who have travelled long distances to seek care from a health facility discourages them from attending the antenatal visits, which exposes them to the risks of maternal health complications. Participants reported long waiting hours at the clinic before being attended to. In worst case scenarios, they would not be attended to, even after waiting for a whole day on empty stomachs.
Although attending ANC enables early diagnosis and reduces maternal and infant morbidity and mortality, financial difficulties limit access to ANC. The illiterate women were mainly housewives who depend on their poor spouses for provision. Supporting them with microenterprise interventions and/or financial incentives such as economic empowerment programs like non-refundable cash could help them meet their pregnancy-related costs. Given the widespread adoption of mobile money applications (money delivered via mobile phones) in Uganda, financial incentives can be delivered directly to women's mobile phones, which they can withdraw from any mobile money agent. This approach can be feasible since mobile phone technology is the most growing technology with over 63.2% of women owning phones in Uganda. Due to lack of access to formal banking services, more than 23.5 million people have mobile money subscriptions. Using mobile money technologies, women can save and receive deposits from their social network for their maternal health on their mobile phones. Alternatively, prearranged transport can be provided using existing community-based mobile transport applications such as Safe Bodas, Uber, and Taxify. Mobile-based applications can also be used to help a mother locate the nearest relevant clinic to minimize the problem of long distances.,,
Unfriendly maternal health services, e.g., denial of services can result in double spending on transport in case of rescheduled appointment or missed appointments due to the lack of transport to the clinic or denial of permission from the spouse. Disrespectful and rude communication is associated with no use of antenatal services, late initiation of antenatal care, no use of facility-based deliveries, and low participation of men in maternal health.,,,,, Utilizing mobile health has the potential to relax the existing challenges in Uganda that result in unfriendly services. This can be through providing quick access to information to illiterate women, ensuring adequate and qualitative interaction between the healthcare workers and pregnant woman, which helps in reducing the amount of time spent at the health facilities and issues of being bounced back. For instance, we are currently implementing a randomized control trail (NCT04089800) that utilizes mobile phone-based multimedia application to provide maternal health information, electronic consultations, and antenatal appointment reminders to illiterate women in the same setting. This application can potentially improve interaction between pregnant women and healthcare providers since women can directly call healthcare providers using their mobile phones. The application can also reduce unnecessary delays at the clinic through remote accessibility of maternal health information, thus relieving women from being exhausted by long waiting hours, losing productive times, going above the timelines allowed by their husbands and spending on transport to the clinic. Mobile phone-enabled technologies can also facilitate remote monitoring for danger signs, labour, and pregnancy-related blood pressure.,,,,,
The main strength of this study is that it identifies the key insights about barriers limiting the access and utilization of maternal health services among illiterate rural women in a rural sub-Saharan African setting. It also highlights the potentials of mobile health technologies in addressing maternal health related barriers. The findings have implications for similar settings although cultural differences may differ. However, results may have limited generalizability as they are based on a small pilot study, but the achievement of theme saturation generally suggests the sample was adequate.
| Conclusion|| |
In sum, lack of money for transport and medical costs, unfriendly maternal health services, and delays at maternal health clinics continue to make women lose their lives while giving lives in Uganda. Mobile technologies can potentially address some of these barriers, e.g., by delivering financial incentives through mobile money technologies and enabling remote access of maternal health services. Physicians in primary care facilities need to always bear in mind that the utilization of current mobile health technologies for the provision of maternal health-related services not only improves the quality of care among pregnant women but also enhances the delivery of healthy babies. The integration and incorporation of mobile health technologies in the primary care system has the potential to ensure universal access to maternal health-related information. More research is needed to assess the utilization of mobile health technologies to support maternal and child health especially in low resource settings.
The study was registered with ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT04089800).
Declaration of patient consent
The authors certify that they have obtained all appropriate patient consent forms. In the form the patients have given their consent for their images and other clinical information to be reported in the journal. The patients understand that their names and initials will not be published and due efforts will be made to conceal their identity, but anonymity cannot be guaranteed.
The authors would like to acknowledge the contributions of Richard Glander, Phionah Kobutungi, Elly Bangumya, Aaron Mugaba, Ezrah Muhindo, Davis Byamugisha, and Richard Ninsiima.
Financial support and sponsorship
The study was funded by a grant from the German Ministry of Education and Research, under the German-African Innovation Incentive Award (01DG18004). AM is also supported by the Fogarty International Center of the National Institutes of Health (K43TW010388).
The content of this paper is entirely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the German Ministry of Education and Research.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
WHO. Trends in maternal mortality 2000 to 2017: Estimates by WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank Group and the United Nations Population Division. 2019.
UNDP. Sustainable development Goals. United Nations Development Programme. 2015.
Lincetto O, Mothebesoane-Anoh S, Gomez P, Munjanja S. Antenatal care. Opportunities for Africa's Newborns: Practical Data, Policy and Programmatic Support for Newborn Care in Africa. 2006. p. 55-62.
UDHS. Health Survey 2016: Key Indicators Report. Kampala, Uganda and Rockville, Maryland. 2016.
Kawungezi PC, AkiiBua D, Aleni C, Chitayi M, Niwaha A, Kazibwe A, et al
. Attendance and utilization of antenatal care (ANC) services: Multi-center study in upcountry areas of Uganda. Open J Prev Med 2015;5:132-42.
Rutaremwa G, Wandera SO, Jhamba T, Akiror E, Kiconco A. Determinants of maternal health services utilization in Uganda. BMC Health Serv Res 2015;15:271.
Karlsen S, Say L, Souza J-P, Hogue CJ, Calles DL, Gülmezoglu AM, et al
. The relationship between maternal education and mortality among women giving birth in health care institutions: Analysis of the cross sectional WHO Global Survey on Maternal and Perinatal Health. BMC Public Health 2011;11:606.
Wilunda C, Quaglio G, Putoto G, Lochoro P, Dall'Oglio G, Manenti F, et al
. A qualitative study on barriers to utilisation of institutional delivery services in Moroto and Napak districts, Uganda: Implications for programming. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2014;14:259.
Morgan R, Tetui M, Muhumuza Kananura R, Ekirapa-Kiracho E, George A. Gender dynamics affecting maternal health and health care access and use in Uganda. Health Policy Plan 2017;32(suppl_5):v13-v21.
Hsieh H-F, Shannon SE. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res 2005;15:1277-88.
WHO. World Health Organization, 2016. WHO Recommendations on Antenatal Care for a Positive Pregnancy Experience. World Health Organization; 2016.
Ellis C, Chaffin J. Evaluations of outcomes for children and youth from NGO-supported microeconomic interventions: A research synthesis. Enterp Dev Microfinance 2015;26:104-21.
Reed E, West BS, Salazar M, Monroy RV. Economic Empowerment to Improve Sexual and Reproductive Health Among Women and Girls. In: Global Perspectives on Women's Sexual and Reproductive Health Across the Lifecourse. Springer; 2018. p. 297-315.
NITA-U. National Information Technology Survey Report 2017/2018. 2018.
Aldrich E. Transport-related delays and maternal mortality in Uganda: The effects of managed and controlled mobility on maternal health and well-being 2014.
Balaam M, Comber R, Jenkins E, Sutton S, Garbett A, editors. FeedFinder: A location-mapping mobile application for breastfeeding women. Proceedings of the 33rd
Annual ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 2015.
Maitra A, Kuntagod N, editors. A novel mobile application to assist maternal health workers in rural India. 2013 5th
International Workshop on Software Engineering in Health Care (SEHC). IEEE; 2013.
Rotheram-Borus MJ, Tomlinson M, Swendeman D, Lee A, Jones E. Standardized functions for smartphone applications: Examples from maternal and child health. Int J Telemed Appl 2012;2012:973237.
Munabi-Babigumira S, Glenton C, Willcox M, Nabudere H. Ugandan health workers' and mothers' views and experiences of the quality of maternity care and the use of informal solutions: A qualitative study. PloS One 2019;14:e0213511.
Kyaddondo D, Mugerwa K, Byamugisha J, Oladapo OT, Bohren MA. Expectations and needs of Ugandan women for improved quality of childbirth care in health facilities: A qualitative study. Int J Gynecol Obstet 2017;139:38-46.
Mgata S, Maluka SO. Factors for late initiation of antenatal care in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania: A qualitative study. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2019;19:415.
Mpembeni RN, Kakoko DC, Aasen HS, Helland I. Realizing women's right to maternal health: A study of awareness of rights and utilization of maternal health services among reproductive age women in two rural districts in Tanzania. PloS One 2019;14:e0216027.
Muheirwe F, Nuhu S. Are health care facilities and programs in Western Uganda encouraging or discouraging men's participation in maternal and child health care? Int J Health Plan Manage 2019;34:263-76.
Tumusiime DK, Agaba G, Kyomuhangi T, Finch J, Kabakyenga J, MacLeod S. Introduction of mobile phones for use by volunteer community health workers in support of integrated community case management in Bushenyi District, Uganda: Development and implementation process. BMC Health Serv Res 2014;14(Suppl 1):S2.
Sondaal SFV, Browne JL, Amoakoh-Coleman M, Borgstein A, Miltenburg AS, Verwijs M, et al
. Assessing the effect of mHealth interventions in improving maternal and neonatal care in low-and middle-income countries: A systematic review. PloS One 2016;11:e0154664.
Barron P, Pillay Y, Fernandes A, Sebidi J, Allen R. The MomConnect mHealth initiative in South Africa: Early impact on the supply side of MCH services. J Public Health Policy 2016;37:201-12.
Poorman E, Gazmararian J, Elon L, Parker R. Is health literacy related to health behaviors and cell phone usage patterns among the text4baby target population? Arch Public Health 2014;72:13.
Frizzo-Barker J, Chow-White PA. “There's an App for That” Mediating mobile moms and connected careerists through smartphones and networked individualism. Feminist Media Stud 2012;12:580-9.
Shah N, Fonner C, Manders N, Aysola R, Sutton S, and Sanchez J. Remote health monitoring platform reduces blood pressure and crisis hypertension. Hypertension 2019;74(Suppl_1):A028-A028.
[Table 1], [Table 2]