|Year : 2021 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 158-166
Attitudes, beliefs, and self-use of Kabasura Kudineer among urban and rural population in Tamil Nadu, India: A comparative cross-sectional study
Public Health Dentistry, SRM University of Science and Technology, Ramapuram, Tamil Nadu, India
|Date of Submission||20-Aug-2020|
|Date of Decision||06-Oct-2020|
|Date of Acceptance||24-Nov-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||30-Jan-2021|
Dr. Dharani Bala
No 9 A Thirumalai Raja St, Joint Office, Ayanavaram, Chennai - 23, Tamil Nadu
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Context: During an earlier outbreak of dengue (DENV), chikungunya (CHIKV) and swine flu in Tamil Nadu, India, Kabasura Kudineer and Nilavembu Kudineer were used to control the febrile episodes. No research is conducted in the past to understand the attitude and beliefs of people towards using Kabasura Kudineer as a means to improve immunity in people, especially in Tamil Nadu, the birthplace of Siddha medicine which led the researcher to conduct the study. Aims: The researcher in the present paper aims to understand the attitude, belief and self-use of Kabasura Kudineer among people in Tamil Nadu, India. Settings and Design: A cross-sectional questionnaire survey was conducted among various people in Tamilnadu, India wherein data was collected from 200 participants. Methods and Material: A cross-sectional study involving explanatory/descriptive research design was considered for the study. Statistical Analysis Used: For the analysis of collected data statistical package for SPSS software version 25.0 was used. Results: The urban participants who participated in the study were 80.5% and the rural participants were 19.5%. The significant P value (0.002) indicated that people use kabasura kudineer because allopathic medicine is less effective medicine and the significant P value (0.001) shows that kabasura kudineer is taken as a self-medication among Tamil Nadu people. Conclusions: The findings of the study revealed the better empowerment of people in the select region towards the use of Kabasura Kudineer.
Keywords: Complementary and Alternative Medicines (CAMs), immunization, Kabasura Kudineer
|How to cite this article:|
Bala D. Attitudes, beliefs, and self-use of Kabasura Kudineer among urban and rural population in Tamil Nadu, India: A comparative cross-sectional study. J Family Med Prim Care 2021;10:158-66
|How to cite this URL:|
Bala D. Attitudes, beliefs, and self-use of Kabasura Kudineer among urban and rural population in Tamil Nadu, India: A comparative cross-sectional study. J Family Med Prim Care [serial online] 2021 [cited 2021 Aug 5];10:158-66. Available from: https://www.jfmpc.com/text.asp?2021/10/1/158/307941
| Introduction|| |
The alarming increase in the disease rates and the global population that are vulnerable to diseases nowadays is attributed to pollution, unhealthy lifestyle and environmental toxins created by mankind itself. The primary concerns of research practitioners in the field of medicine and healthcare are towards addressing the adverse effects caused due to drug abuse which has necessitated assurance of quality, safety and potency of the medicine. One of the proven methods to control and eliminate deadly diseases that cause more than 3 million deaths every year is immunization. An idea to gain immunity is immunity “boost“, which is popular because of its vast knowledge and exposure in the field of medicine and healthcare. However, the usage of no proof-based approaches to improve or boost immunity in human population as a potential substitute for vaccination is a debatable topic. Immunisation is gaining momentum in the recent years owing to the increase in the number of communicable diseases. Though vaccination is considered with great importance, mental resistance towards vaccination is also becoming a big threat in the international arena as per the reports of WHO.
Researches in the past have revealed the importance of improving immunity among people living in different parts of the world., The utilization of alternative medicines along with vitamins, was associated with the reduction in the levels of vaccination.
The bane of Allopathic vaccination is that it has research-based records on safety downfall which neutralizes its remarkable benefits. Complementary and Alternative Medicines (CAMs) have proven to boost immune reactions over diseases. CAMs are conventional methods which may help enhance psychological standards of life and lessen the possibility of infection. Hence. it is important to additionally evaluate the benefits of alternative medicine and other immunity-boosting supplements, particularly vitamins. Plant-based drugs are deemed safe to humans and their surroundings compared to other artificial formulations in so-called modern era in which people live today. 25%of the total herbaceous drugs are estimated to be in utilization in the US whereas in emerging countries such as India and China, its usage is nearly 80%. Ayurveda medicines predominantly practiced in India and other major systems of indigenous medicines such as Siddha, Homeopathy, Unani and Folk (tribal) alternative treatments are deemed to be alternative medicines with equal potential as that of conventional allopathic drugs.
In agreement with the increasing importance of alternative medicines, WHO established an act called 'WHO Traditional Medicine Strategy 2014-2023' in 2013 which asserted to amalgamate traditional and complementary medicine to improve global healthcare. As a result, the world seeks for economical, accessible, and more physiologically amicable conventional system of medicine and holistic approach to start such predicaments and administer everyone their basic healthcare needs. WHO states that 80% of global population still relies on conventional medicines for their healthcare needs. The marked utilisation of plant substances for a broad spectrum of human diseases in developing nations are associated with overpopulation, sparse supply of drugs, costly treatment options, adverse effects of counterfeit drugs, and drug resistance. The need for development of novel and safer drugs are due to the limitations provided by some effective drugs such as aspirin, phenylbutazone, indomethacin, etc., though they do not produce any adverse effects. With the growth of new antibiotics, resistance towards the antibiotics also increases which induces other chronic conditions. As a result of medicine abuse, WHO has put forth herbal medicines as their primary sources of healthcare in several countries like India.
In India, several problems are treated using CAMs such as, Ayurveda, Siddha, Unani, Homeopathy, Yoga and naturopathy. The use of plant-based products in developed countries is increased which is due to the changes in lifestyle and decreased affordability to allopathic medicine by the present-day population. Ayurvedic medicine's ideology on health and diseases is based on the use of plant-based compounds, exceptional diets and other distinctive health rituals. The greater predilection towards conventional medicines is due to money and time. It can also be ultimately encouraged to be a part with other pharmaceutical products. As a result, studies are conducted to improve the understanding and knowledge on alternative medicines used by patients and medical practitioners.
Though COVID 19 has gained the researcher's attention throughout the world, research on treatment using organic products are limited. A review has been organized by Bchetnia M et al., on global SARS-COV-2 current condition and found that it was a communicable disease related to airway disorders that causes acute respiratory distress syndrome and severe pneumonia. However, there are no specific treatment proven, the study was based on meta-analysis of SARS-COV-2 and Coronavirus. They have published a report on clinical, epidemiology, pathology, phylo-genetic origin and transmission of COVID-19 with their treatment options.
Alnefaie A et al., reviewed on treatment of COVID-19 in immune response and molecular mechanism perspective which provides an overview on the types, targeted hosts, time of origin, receptors, role of important elements that kills the pathogens. At the same time, it focuses on the structure and pathogenesis of SARS-COV-2.
Papers on antiviral and bioactive character of organic compounds against coronaviruses have been published. Xian Y et al., organized a review that stated there is a urgent need on prevention and medications against coronavirus. There was evidence of several biological activities along with antiviral properties of organic compounds. Therefore, the author issues an overall review on organic compounds that alters growth of MERS and SARS and also their use for treatment of coronavirus. Shah et al., selected about 30 phyto-compounds from various plants which had antiviral action against coronavirus, and did in silico screening using biscoclaurine, amentoflavone, myricetin, norreticuline and licoricidin by silico approach. The result showed that the compounds have the potential to resist COVID-19.
Another study is conducted on in silico computational screening by Kiran G et al. This study is aimed to execute the In Silico computational studies of phyto-constituents of Siddha official formulation Kabasura Kudineer and novel herbal preparation - JACOM which are commonly used in treating viral fever and respiratory infectious diseases and could be affective against the ongoing pandemic novel coronavirus disease SARS-CoV-2. This study proved that all the phyto-constituents were free from carcinogenic and tumorigenicity properties.
Since enough review of literature is not available to support the use of benefit of natural products like kabasura kudineer, this study was conducted to know the Attitudes, Beliefs, and Self-use of Kabasura Kudineer among Urban and Rural Population in Tamil Nadu, India.
One of the oldest conventional systems of medicine, Siddha has originated from southern part of India, Tamil Nadu. Medicines in Siddha form are classified as external and internal depending on the means of intake and are sub-classified into 32 groups depending on their form, durability, application technique, and so on. Out of the 32 internal medicines, two medicines are recommended by the Indian Government to treat viral infections- they are Kabasura Kudineer chooranam (for swine flu) and Nilavembu Kudineer chooranam (for chikunguniya and dengue).
During an earlier outbreak of dengue (DENV), chikungunya (CHIKV) and swine flu in Tamil Nadu, India, Kabasura Kudineer and Nilavembu Kudineer were used to control the febrile episodes 17,18. [Table 1] displays the composition involved in the synthesis of the Kabasura Kudineer. The present global pandemic has increased the public attention towards the benefits of Kabasura Kudineer in Tamil Nadu. Therefore, the author believes that understanding the people's attitude in the use of Kabasura Kudineer will help increasing immunity levels and controlling the spread of communicable diseases among general public. Considering the importance by the Government of Tamil Nadu and the Government of India on recommending Kabasura Kudineer as a means to fight viral infections and improve immunity, it is of great importance to research about the medicine; however, scanty researches are available. Furthermore, there is no evidence whether people who live in Tamil Nadu, which serves as the origin for Siddha medicine know about this medicine and its efficacy. Against this backdrop, the researcher aims to understand the attitude, belief and self-use of Kabasura Kudineer among people in Tamil Nadu, India.
| Subjects and Methods|| |
A cross-sectional questionnaire survey was conducted among various people in Tamilnadu, India. Nineteen closed-ended questions were framed and validated by the research experts before conducting the study. The questionnaire was divided to assess the knowledge, belief, attitude and self-use among the participants on the kabasura kudineer. The questionnaire was validated by the experts in the field of public health and content validity was done. The study was conducted in the month of June 2020. The questionnaire was passed on to the individual through Google forms through the Internet platform. Convenience sampling was done to select the participants included in the study. The finalised questions were divided into five types which include demographic details of the participants which include gender distribution, residence, living status, occupation and religion. This study involved 200 participants.
The main framework of the questionnaire includes the knowledge related questions were framed as closed-ended questionnaire and other variable which include belief, attitude and self use were framed according to Likert scale as strongly disagree, disagree, neutral, agree and strongly agree. Kappa statistics was calculated to find the Inter and intra examiner comparison and found the value of 0.91 which is considered to be good agreement. SPSS software version 25.0 (SPSS Inc, Illinois, Chicago, USA) was used for statistical analysis. Descriptive statistics was performed to known the demographic Characterstics of the participants included in the study along with the percentage distribution of questionnaire recorded. Chi-square test was carried to find out the association between the rural and urban population on perception of kabasura kudineer questionnaire included in the study among study population Inferential statistics was performed using Chi-square test, correlation analysis and unpaired t test to find out the correlation between urban and rural population. Ethical certificate approval was obtained (Approval Number: SRMU/M&HS/SRMDC/2020/UG/001, Date: 19/10/2020) from institution review board SRM Dental College, Ramapuram, Chennai- 89.).
| Results|| |
[Table 2] shows the demographic characteristic of the participants included in the study. In gender distribution, it was found that 59% of females and 41% of males were included in the study. The status of residence includes that 80.5% of urban.
[Table 3] shows knowledge the participants had regarding the kabasura kudineer. The two questionnaires which were framed to record the knowledge showed that the source of knowledge they gained about kabasura kudineer is much from family, friends or neighbours which was 62%. While recording the response of how many participants used kabasura kudineer for which particular disease condition, it was found that 70% of participants used for Cough/cold/flu and other respiratory problems.
|Table 3: Questionnaire based on knowledge of kabasura kudineer among the participants|
Click here to view
[Figure 1] shows the source of knowledge they gained about kabasura kudineer is much from family, friends or neighbours which was 62%.
|Figure 1: The characteristic distribution between the source of knowledge the participants obtained about kabasura kudineer expressed in percentage|
Click here to view
[Figure 2] shows that While recording the response of how many participants used kabasura kudineer for which particular disease condition, it was found that 70% of participants used for Cough/cold/flu and other respiratory problems.
|Figure 2: The characteristic distribution between Disease conditions for which Kabasura Kudineer was consumed is expressed in percentage|
Click here to view
[Table 4] shows the correlation analysis between the urban and rural population belief towards the kabasura kudineer and found that nearly for all the question the maximum response of urban and rural population is in neutral option.
|Table 4: Questionnaire based on participants belief towards kabasura kudineer|
Click here to view
[Table 5] shows the participants attitude towards the kabasura kudineer and found that almost for all the 5 questions asked the participants answered a neutral and agree option as maximum. Here correlation analysis was done to find out the correlation between the urban and rural population. P < 0.05 was found to be statistically significant.
|Table 5: Questionnaire based on participants attitude towards kabasura kudineer|
Click here to view
[Table 6] shows the perception of self use of kabasura kudineer by asking four questionnaire and found that almost for all the question the response from the participants had a mixed answers of all the 5 Likert scale options.
|Table 6: Questionnaire based on participants self use of kabasura kudineer|
Click here to view
[Table 7] shows the association between the rural and urban population among the participants included in the study using person Chi-square test. P < 0.05 was considered as statistically significant. This table interprets that one question related to attitude and one question related to self-use was found to be statistically significant association between urban and rural population by obtaining a P < 0.05.
|Table 7: Inferential Characteristics of the questionnaire recorded among the rural and urban population|
Click here to view
[Table 8] shows the results of unpaired t test using the mean and standard deviation analysis among the rural and urban population and found a significant result for one of the questions related to the attitude towards kabasura kudineer. Statistically significant values are P < 0.05.
|Table 8: Unpaired t-test was computed for the questionnaire recorded among the rural and urban population included in the study|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Prevention is better than cure and kabasura kudineer acts as a preventive remedy to avoid the serious illness of covid-19. Kabasura kudineer is available in chooranam or powder form and was used at the time of swine-flu which is also considered as pandemic disease. Kabasura kudineer as such is used to treat all the respiratory problems which include cold, fever, severe phlegm and flu. Kabasura kudineer not only cures viral infection but also plays important role in treating the bacterial infection. It also helps to cure inflammation in lungs and digestive problems. The present study shows that while recording the demographic details the number of females were more in number went compared to males, which went expressed in percentage was 59% of female and 41% of males respectively. The urban participants participated in the study was 80.5% and the rural participants were 19.5%. Almost 63% of the participants were students and other were employed and more number of religion includes Hindu participants included in the study which accounts 77%.
Questionnaire related to knowledge of kabasura kudineer includes the source of knowledge, information and for what disease condition they consume kabasura kudineer in which maximum percentage, i.e 62% of the participants gathered information about kabasura kudineer from their friends, family or neighbours. Cough/cold/flu and other respiratory problems were answered by 70% of the participants went asked about the disease condition they consume kabasura kudineer. Gangarapu et al. has proved that nearly 9 compounds showed a positive response against the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein which will help the people to resist from the infection. Questionnaire related to the belief towards kabasura kudineer includes 8 questions in which 51.9% of the participants in urban and 48.7% of rural population believe that kabasura kudineer was effective and 49.4% in urban and 53.8% of rural population had neutral response among the participants believed that it was safer than any other drug in allopathic medicine. In the cost criteria, it was found that 48.8% of urban and 48.7% answered the kabasura kudineer was less expensive than allopathic medicine and 56.3% of urban population agree and 43.6% of rural population strongly agree that it was a natural product. Neutral answer was found went answered about side effects of allopathic medicine than kabasura kudineer which recorded as 33.1% in urban population and 46.2% in rural population respectively.
Among the urban population 46.9% and 48.7%% rural population agreed that it will maintain the overall health of the individual and 43.1% or urban had a neutral opinion and 43.6% had an agreed opinion that it was better than allopathic medicine. The participants had a neutral response went asked about the permanent cure of the disease while consuming kabasura kudineer and found 40.6% in urban and 53.8% among rural population. Questionnaire related to the attitude towards kabasura kudineer includes 5 questions in which 39.4% in urban population and 41% among rural had a neutral opinion about the use of kabasura kudineer is less effective than allopathic medicine and is more natural which was agreed with 50.6% among the urban and 48.7% among the rural population. Almost 40.6% in urban agreed and 35.9% of rural population disagreed that they used it due to trust in the product and 43% agreed to maintain their health and well being and 41.3% among the urban and 48.7% among the rural agreed that they consume both kabasura kudineer and allopathic medicine. Correlation analysis was done to find out the correlation between the questions asked to record the belief and attitude none of them obtained a P value of < 0.05, so it was found that the urban and rural population had different opinions on kabasura kudineer.
Questionnaire related to the self use towards kabasura kudineer includes 4 a question in which 42.5% among urban and 28.2% in rural agreed to use kabasura kudineer as self medication and 34.4% of urban and 48.7% of rural population gave a neutral response is consuming kabasura kudineer when the disease is simple. While assessing the reason for consuming kabasura kudineer because no hospital was nearby 46.3% of urban and 48.7% of rural population disagree to this reason and 34.4% of urban and 48.7% of rural gave a neutral opinion on consuming kabasura kudineer due to lack of trust in allopathic medicine. While assessing the association between the rural and urban population using Chi-square test, the value of P was obtained to be <0.05 which is statistically significant for using kabasura kudineer as self medication and they consume since they found allopathic medicine less effective than kabasura kudineer.
While assessing the mean and standard deviation using unpaired t test for the question asked to assess the belief, attitude and self use of kabasura kudineer it was found that P value was considered as statistically significant while recording that kabasura kudineer was found to be natural than allopathic medicine and P value obtained as <0.05.
Inspite of government initiated to find various vaccines and other treatment kabasura kudineer might be suggested as an home remedy to avoid serious illness., The government initiated the use of nilavembu kudineer to prevent dengue and chikungunya virus as such to prevent the covid-19 infection kabasura kudineer can be used as effective method., The limitation of the study includes, since the review of literature on kabasura kudineer was less appreciable to calculate the sample size we choose convenience sampling technique.
In conclusion, the urban and rural population have a different opinion on kabasura kudineer. The urban population have strong beliefs and attitudes towards the use of kabasura kudineer than the rural population. However, both types of the population have a neutral opinion on consuming kabasura kudineer due to lack of trust in allopathic medicine and when the disease is simple. Tamil Nadu people gathered information about kabasura kudineer from their friends, family or neighbours and they take kabasura kudineer as a self-medication. This result could help the government and primary care physicians to encourage the use of kabasura kudineer to enhance the immunity of the general public.
Kabasura kudineer can always be used as a home remedy to boost up immunity and prevent from viral and fungal infection. In the present study it has proved than the person's opinion in consuming kabasura kudineer among the urban and rural population was they believe that kabasura kudineer is found to be cost effective than allopathic medicine and used as a self medication to provoke our body from resisting all types of fungal and viral infection. People find that kabasura kudineer has less side effects when compared to allopathic medicine since it is found to contain natural product. However, the researcher finds that there is a need to improve the attitude of people towards using Kabasura kudineer on safe ways through the prescription of acclaimed Siddha doctors and practitioners. The researcher further recommends the need to increase research in a direction where the efficacy, safety and potential of Siddha medicines are to be tested using clinical trials. The researcher also recommends future researches to be conducted to understand the attitude of people in other regions of the nation to acquire more insights and the ways to promote CAMs to improve immunity, especially to the vulnerable population of the nation. Such studies will act as benchmark for other developing nations to improve their stance in the health care sector.
The authors thank the participants of various people in Tamil Nadu for their contribution during data collection. Further I would like to give special thanks to my advisors Dr. Lubna Fathima and Harini for all their help and guidance.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
WHO. Immunization. World Health Organization. 2020.
WHO. Ten Threats to Global Health in 2019. World Health Organization. 2019.
Bleser WK, Elewonibi BR, Miranda PY, BeLue R. Complementary and alternative medicine and influenza vaccine uptake in US children. Pediatrics 2016;138:e20154664.
Browne M, Thomson P, Rockloff MJ, Pennycook G. Going against the herd: Psychological and cultural factors underlying the 'Vaccination Confidence Gap.' Perales JC, editor. PLoS One 2015;10:e0132562.
Miller N. First do no harm: Scientific evidence implicating allopathic vaccination. Homoeopathic Links2016;29:091–6.
Nilashi M, Samad S, Yusuf SYM, Akbari E. Can complementary and alternative medicines be beneficial in the treatment of COVID-19 through improving immune system function? J Infect Public Health 2020;13:893–6.
Rajkumar RP. Ayurveda and COVID-19: Where psychoneuroimmunology and the meaning response meet. Brain Behav Immun 2020;87:8–9.
Wiwanitkit V. Swine flu: The present pandemic infectious disease. Kulak Burun Bogaz Ihtis Derg 2009;19:57–61.
Sen S, Chakraborty R. Revival, modernization and integration of Indian traditional herbal medicine in clinical practice: Importance, challenges and future. J Tradit Complement Med 2017;7:234–44.
Meshram GG, Kumar A, Rizvi W, Tripathi CD, Khan RA. Evaluation of the anti-inflammatory activity of the aqueous and ethanolic extracts of the leaves of Albizzia lebbeck in rats. J Tradit Complement Med 2016;6:172–5.
Senthilkumar CS, Balakrishnan N. Pseudoscientific beliefs and practices in the COVID-19 pandemic: A narrative review of unwanted experiments attributed to social media-based misinformation afflicting the public health. J Health Biol Sci 2020;8:1-9.
Junaid A, Anusooya D, Tamilselvi A, Suriani I, Rosliza A. The concept of Ayurveda in Medical Science, An Indian Traditional Medicine: A review. Int J Public Health Clin Sci 2017;4:15-23
Bchetnia M, Girard C, Duchaine C, Laprise C. The outbreak of the novel severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2): A review of the current global status. J Infect Public Health 2020. doi: S1876-0341 (20) 30591-8.
Alnefaie A, Albogami S. Current approaches used in treating COVID-19 from a molecular mechanisms and immune response perspective. Saudi Pharm J 2020. doi: 10.1016/j.jsps. 2020.08.024.
Xian Y, Zhang J, Bian Z, Zhou H, Zhang Z, Lin Z, et al
. Bioactive natural compounds against human coronaviruses: A review and perspective. Acta Pharm Sin B 2020;10:1163–74.
Shah A, Patel V, Parmar B. Discovery of some antiviral natural products to fight against Novel Corona virus (SARS-CoV-2) using Insilico approach. Comb Chem High Throughput Screen 2020. doi: 10.2174/1386207323666200902135928.
Kiran G, Karthik L, Shree Devi MS, Sathiyarajeswaran P, Kanakavalli K, Kumar KM, et al
. In Silico computational screening of Kabasura Kudineer-Official Siddha Formulation and JACOM against SARS-CoV-2 spike protein. J Ayurveda Integr Med 2020. doi: 10.1016/j.jaim. 2020.05.009.
Mekala P, Gopala Krishna Murthy T. Phytochemical screening and pharmacological update on Kabasura Kudineer Choornam and Nilavembu Kudineer Choornam. J Pharmacogn Phytochem 2020;9:1031–6.
Pitchiah Kumar M, Meenakshi Sundaram K, Ramasamy MS. Coronavirus Spike (S) Glycoprotein (2019-Ncov) Targeted Siddha Medicines Kabasura Kudineer and Thonthasura Kudineer –In silico Evidence for Corona Viral Drug. AJPRHC 2019;11:1–9.
Shanmugavelu M. Noi Nadal Noi Mudhal Nadal Thirattu Part-I (in Tamil). Chennai: Directorate of Indian Medicine & Homeopathy; 2014.
Shih H-I, Wu C-J, Tu Y-F, Chi C-Y. Fighting COVID-19: A quick review of diagnoses, therapies, and vaccines. Biomed J 2020;43:341-54.
Tu Y-F, Chien C-S, Yarmishyn AA, Lin Y-Y, Luo Y-H, Lin Y-T, et al
. A review of SARS-CoV-2 and the ongoing clinical trials. Int J Mol Sci 2020;21:2657.
Jain J, Pai S, Sunil S. Standardization of in vitro
assays to evaluate the activity of polyherbal siddha formulations against Chikungunya virus infection. Virusdisease 2018;29:32–9.
Jain J, Kumar A, Narayanan V, Ramaswamy RS, Sathiyarajeswaran P, Shree Devi MS, et al
. Antiviral activity of ethanolic extract of Nilavembu Kudineer against dengue and chikungunya virus through in vitro
evaluation. J Ayurveda Integr Med 2019;11:329-35.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2]
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6], [Table 7], [Table 8]